TV and Film Gone Green by Ditching Green Screen: Sustainable Innovation Through the Lense of ‘The Mandalorian’ [21068606]

What is ‘The Mandalorian’?

Currently in its third season, ‘The Mandalorian’, first released in 2019, has lead the innovation of virtual production in both Television and Film. The series immerses itself into the Star Wars universe, where we follow a lone bounty hunter running away from imperial forces across the galaxy. The well-established Sci-fi universe meant that the production thrusts itself into producing a magnificent array of visual effects to bring this fictional world to life.

Video Created by Star Wars on YouTube, 2023

With a great demand for outstanding visual effects, came the introduction of a revolutionary innovation that has altered the way TV and Film in the genre of sci-fi and fantasy is filmed. Ditching the green screen and introducing virtual production of ‘StageCraft.’

What is StageCraft?

Created by a pioneering company known for their ground-breaking creations in visual effects, ILM (Industrial Light and Magic) partnered with Epic Games (Creator of ‘Unreal Engine) developing a virtual production set made up of LED walls that are programmed to show a photorealistic 3D world. The screen walls are known by the cast and crew as ‘The Volume’, which is 20 feet tall, 75 feet in diameter and covers 270 degrees of the set, illuminating an immersive set for all the cast and crew.

For shows like ‘The Mandalorian’, fans expect to be transported to an alternative world, or galaxy, which creates a complex task for the filmmakers on each of the projects. Green screens are used so that during post production, they can later add the special effects or CGI. This meant that during production, the actors and crew have to use their imaginations and guess what the visuals will end up looking like. Consequently, film productions use multiple lighting techniques around the set in order to irradiate the green screen glare and create realistic lighting that would match the final image on the screen.

By using the LED video walls, it irradiates the need for additional lighting techniques and the excessive post-production process, as it already delivers the lighting and imagery needed to bring the worlds to life. Additionally, everyone involved in the production is more immersed and inspired whilst creating the project, making sure everyone is on the same page while filming

How is it sustainable?

In the last couple decades, industry policies regarding cinema have made suggestions on how to become ‘greener’ and more sustainable. The aim? To reduce the industry’s overall negative environmental impact. The ‘SPA’ (Sustainable Production Alliance) is a combination of the worlds leading film, television and streaming companies, supporting the objective of advancing sustainable initiatives. The Green Production Guide, prepared by the ‘SPA’, is an online toolkit designed to reduce industry carbon footprints by evaluating ways in which productions can be more environmentally friendly and energy efficient. One thing the guide, and other sustainable missions analyse, is the switch to LED technology, as it converts a higher percentage of energy into light, producing less heat, and in return less carbon emissions.

StageCraft aligns itself with sustainable industry governance, as ‘The Volume’ uses LED’s for its video wall, using 70% less energy then incandescent lights, further cutting its carbon emissions. Not only that, but it can bring locations to the comfort of ‘The Volume’! The production avoids having to travel sets, props and crews to distant locations, lessening fuel and time waisted.

Marissa Gomes (ILM visual effects producer): “You can switch from the Iceland to the desert locations all within the same day of shooting”

Video created by StudioBinder on YouTube, 2023

This groundbreaking technology has forced productions into a more efficient workflow, that draws pre and post production into one space. With crews covering 30-50% more pages a day, not only is virtual production sustainable environmentally, but it also saves time and money.

The Star Wars franchise has been used to explore film and TV’s environmental impact, due to its high production value. With the research conducted by ‘The EIF Project’, Star Wars, including ‘The Mandalorian’, continues to affiliate with improving sustainability goals.

StageCraft going global

Some other productions that have used StageCraft included ‘Thor: Love and Thunder’ (2022), ‘Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania’ (2023), and most recently ‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ (2024). Permanent volumes have been built in Los Angeles, London, and Sydney, whilst ILM have alluded to their ability to provide “pop up” sets, which allows multiple productions to reuse and access the video wall soundstage. Large productions can invest in StageCraft, which can eliminate other production elements that take up a lot of time and money, adding to the positive long-term efficiency, rather than having to create large sets from scratch and wasting materials.

The Future

Overall, the system looks more realistic then a green screen, and allows for quicker setups in a controlled environment. There is one drawback of this new technology, which is limited camera movement. This is for moving shots where someone could be running away for a long amount of time. But just as there were drawbacks of green screen, companies light ‘ILM’ continue to create and improve, whilst also having a sustainable practice in mind. The innovation initiated for “The Mandalorian” is beginning to revolutionise the film industry and push for standards towards sustainability.

Does policy influence equality in the theatre industry? LGBTQ+ presence on and off the stage in the UK.

By C1905618

The glitz and glamour surrounding the West End and Broadway are the hottest places to see our names up in lights. The LGBTQ+ community have become synonymous with all things theatre, especially in the UK. Anyone and everyone are welcome on the stage. Theatres and the UK government have even developed policies around inclusivity to create space for this. But is LGBTQ+ presence on stage any more visible than in previous years?

Notable cultural quarters like Cardiff and London overflow with spaces for LGBTQ+ people to thrive. Theatre companies and groups receive substantial funding and appointed policies ensuring equal opportunities for all and saying a big no-no to the discrimination of creative practitioners. Thanks to the Equality Act of 2010 and theatre policies improving equality in the creative sectors, the theatre has become a place where LGBTQ+ presence thrives with career opportunities and reoccurring LGBTQ+ storylines… Right?….

Letters Waiting in the Wings

Source: Broadway Box Photo Gallery via Google Images

A colourful portfolio of LGBTQ+ storylines reoccurs annually on British stages and is touring globally. Popular shows from  Kinky Boots – a musical based on the British film surrounding a shoe factory and drag culture – to smaller musicals such as Hedwig and the Angry Inch – a musical covering a botched sex-change operation and exclusion of a German emigrant rock singer. Furthermore, Drag performances and storylines are entering local theatres and the Westend through arrangements such as Everyone’s Talking About Jamie. But do theatres’ associations with queerness translate equality on and off-stage presence?

Source: MsMojo via YouTube

Notably, the Sherman Theatre’s 2022 production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream reimagined Shakespeare’s classic theatre production. The play, originally written in a heterosexual context, was adapted to portray the lovers as a lesbian couple. The Sherman Theatre’s policies surround ‘tell[ing] local stories with global resonance’ and a place for everyone. Their contribution to LGBTQ+ visibility through their productions demonstrates these policies. Yet, with this fruitful collection of theatre performances, acronyms in the LGBTQ+ continue to be invisible on the stage. The Gs and Ls are growing in visibility across theatre, but what about the others? What about the community’s Bs, Ts, As, and Ps who wish to see themselves through characters onstage?

Statistically, the UK is not lacking in LGBTQ+ citizens. The Gender identity, England and Wales: Census 2021 received 45.7 million respondents aged 16 and over on their gender identity. Cardiff notably had the highest percentage of respondents who identified as trans men (0.12%) and those who identified as trans women (0.13%).

A similar census conducted on sexual orientation received 45.7 million respondents 16 and over. 1.5 million respondents identified with LGBTQ+ sexual orientations. London holds the highest number of LGBTQ+ respondents (4.3%) in the English region, while Cardiff holds the highest (5.3%) in the Welsh region. LGBTQ+ individuals are creating a large community in these spaces, but why is it so hard to find theatres and productions dedicated to their presence?

Is eradication of the past as problematic as previous discourses? 

Younger generations, in particular, have identified the outdatedness of queer representation through previous theatre performances. How younger generations feel about policies implemented to discontinue theatre performances that cause discomfort or offence is understandable. They surface the question: should theatre abolish the continuation of problematic discourses to prevent this?

Notably, the presence of outdated LGBTQ+ storylines and characters on the stage can be an excellent opportunity to learn from previous mistakes. It may sometimes feel uncomfortable, but spaces must be left for queer historical theatre, even if they do not align with updated ideas. These spaces will allow for recognition of theatre’s contribution to the LGBTQ+ community and demonstrate how far they have come. Their existence does not excuse new productions using past problematic discourses, however. Policies should protect their significance in developing more updated understandings of LGBTQ+ representation that will contribute to equality on stage.

All this queerness, nowhere to go.

Source: BGD Interview with Panmai via Google Images

Theatre policies ensuring the safety and inclusion of minority groups are ubiquitous in the UK. Unfortunately, including LGBTQ+ members are still deemed a political statement in the UK and elsewhere. Policies and even laws aren’t always contributing to equality for creative sectors.

Exemplary, 2014 saw the formation of India’s first transgender theatre group, Panmai. The theatre group created and conducted by trans activists – Living Smile Vidya, Angel Glady and Gee Imaan Semmalar – aims to provide opportunities to transgender citizens in India. Vidya mentions the transgender struggles of being subjected and restricted to beggary and sex work propelled by anti-LGBTQ+ communities in India. The group’s policy is to create creative careers for transgender individuals, reducing the social exclusion they often experience.

Although the Supreme Court of India’s 2014 verdict recognises transgender individuals as a ‘third gender’ by law, this has not equated to cultural or social acceptance of LGBTQ+ citizens in India. Similar to many theatres across the globe, Panmai’s policy can create a temporary space for LGBTQ+ members but does not necessarily extend outside the group.

Policies of inclusion and equality do contribute to the visibility of some LGBTQ+ members, but others remain absent from the stage. The presence of bisexuals, asexuals, pansexuals, and gender-fluid individuals on the stage is necessary to consider theatre LGBTQ+ fully inclusive. Theatres can create spaces for LGBTQ+ members to experience inclusion, even if they do not receive it off the stage.

If The 1975 are the present, what about the future of Cardiff’s music scene? (2013920)

A critical review of the cultural economy of The 1975’s show ‘At Their Very Best’, how they continue to remain accessible to audiences and the policy of music in Cardiff. 

Extending over two days in Cardiff’s International Arena The 1975 gave an exhilarating performance in the Welsh capital on their recent worldwide tour ‘At Their Very Best’. The buzz of the audience was electric as they waited in anticipation to see what unique spectacle frontman Matty Healy had in store. His recent antics on stage have gained the media’s attention with viral videos on TikTok of the singer eating raw steak on stage. The show presented a theatre-like stage, with a mock-house and dimply lit lamps. This reference paid homage to their music video ‘Happiness’, with the intimate setting immersing audiences globally. 

The 1975’s creativity is prodigious, connecting to the value of Cardiff as a creative city. Cardiff’s culture within music industry is however beginning to crumble quite literally. With music venues being replaced by modern flats, the agent of change principle to protect music venues at risk to new residents’ complaints needs to continue to be used to stop property developers destroying the arts. 

Singer, Healy sustained a sense of theatrical performance, conforming to the rockstar stereotype, swaying with a glass of wine in his hand. Healy and the band remained flawless as they executed each song from their latest album to perfection. As fans screamed the lyrics, filling the International Arena with vibrancy, the future for this venue remains uncertain. The approval from Cardiff council to demolish the Guildford Crescent in 2019 created outrage, with independent music venue Gwdihŵ being destroyed despite fierce campaigning among citizens. Plans have now been approved by the council for a multi-million pound arena at Cardiff Bay to open in 2025.

Figure 2: By Ruth Sharville on Wikimedia, Creative Commons

How many concert venues in Cardiff can be financially sustainable and what does this mean for the future of the International Arena?

As seen with venues, such as Womanby Street campaigners are not afraid to speak up and save live music in Cardiff. Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Lesley Griffiths shared her support for the movement, stating that she would work with politicians to “create a comprehensive music strategy to support the future of live music in Wales”. Let’s hope that this remains the case for Cardiff’s International Arena, maintaining the cultural well-being of Wales listed in the Well-being of Future Generations Act.

Figure 3: By Live Cardiff on YouTube

The uniqueness of The 1975 was brought to the stage as Healy addressed Cardiff’s crowd for the first time halfway through the show. The mirage was broken with performance art as the music paused and Healy broke ‘the fourth wall’. As extras walked across the stage in laboratory coats Healy discussed the scripted nature of the show, referencing ‘method acting’ as he controlled the extras on stage by snapping his fingers, making them pause on his commands. The interlude continued with the famous act of Healy eating raw steak and doing press-ups with flashing images of Vladimir Putin, Liz Truss and Prince Andrew dazzling the crowd on screen. 

Is this a reference to toxic masculinity in the twenty-first century? 

A statement about the current political climate of the world? 

Or just a bizarre artistic statement to sell more tickets? 

Figure 4: By The 1975 on Instagram

As the audience were left confused pondering on these possibilities Healy crawled into mock TV’s. A possible reference to our unhealthy social media consumption, with screen usage increasing since the pandemic and artists using this for live-streaming concerts which still remains popular post-pandemic

The 1975 have made a statement with their ticket prices which unlike many similar stature bands they have capped at affordable levels. Ticket prices for concerts have soared recently, with 36% of the gig-going public having spent more than £100 on a concert ticket. This unease regarding concert ticketing and the regulation of live events are “all areas of concern for policy makers”, thus a major concern for gig culture. 

Figure 5: Video from @ticketrev on TikTok

The 1975 have remained humble with their ticket prices rarely being above £50, unlike for example, Beyonce’s prices for her return to Cardiff’s Principality Stadium amid the cost of living crisis. As a booming city for the music industry, Cardiff needs more bands performing for reasonable prices. The recognition of music venues as heritage sites is also lacking in the Planning Policy Wales 10. Combined with the rising ticket prices this could raise future issues for the capital’s music industry. 

The dynamic shifted in the second half of the show as the theatrical performance was dropped and the band maintained the thrilling energy, with the early masterpiece of ‘Robbers’ pulling at heart strings. The show concluded with the band leaving through the door of the house, slipping back into the performative role they immersed at the start of the show. The lights came on, with beaming faces of those who know they have just witnessed one of the best part performance and part rock shows of all time. 

The doubt surrounding policy matters within the industry, combined with inflation of ticket prices and venues closing leaves an air of uncertainty for music-lovers. One thing that does remain certain is that passionate nights like The 1975’s performance still excites crowds. Cardiff must not lose this, I believe the community-feel this city holds will continue to captivate dedicated music fans, holding hope for the future of the creative capital’s music scene.