TV and Film Gone Green by Ditching Green Screen: Sustainable Innovation Through the Lense of ‘The Mandalorian’ [21068606]

What is ‘The Mandalorian’?

Currently in its third season, ‘The Mandalorian’, first released in 2019, has lead the innovation of virtual production in both Television and Film. The series immerses itself into the Star Wars universe, where we follow a lone bounty hunter running away from imperial forces across the galaxy. The well-established Sci-fi universe meant that the production thrusts itself into producing a magnificent array of visual effects to bring this fictional world to life.

Video Created by Star Wars on YouTube, 2023

With a great demand for outstanding visual effects, came the introduction of a revolutionary innovation that has altered the way TV and Film in the genre of sci-fi and fantasy is filmed. Ditching the green screen and introducing virtual production of ‘StageCraft.’

What is StageCraft?

Created by a pioneering company known for their ground-breaking creations in visual effects, ILM (Industrial Light and Magic) partnered with Epic Games (Creator of ‘Unreal Engine) developing a virtual production set made up of LED walls that are programmed to show a photorealistic 3D world. The screen walls are known by the cast and crew as ‘The Volume’, which is 20 feet tall, 75 feet in diameter and covers 270 degrees of the set, illuminating an immersive set for all the cast and crew.

For shows like ‘The Mandalorian’, fans expect to be transported to an alternative world, or galaxy, which creates a complex task for the filmmakers on each of the projects. Green screens are used so that during post production, they can later add the special effects or CGI. This meant that during production, the actors and crew have to use their imaginations and guess what the visuals will end up looking like. Consequently, film productions use multiple lighting techniques around the set in order to irradiate the green screen glare and create realistic lighting that would match the final image on the screen.

By using the LED video walls, it irradiates the need for additional lighting techniques and the excessive post-production process, as it already delivers the lighting and imagery needed to bring the worlds to life. Additionally, everyone involved in the production is more immersed and inspired whilst creating the project, making sure everyone is on the same page while filming

How is it sustainable?

In the last couple decades, industry policies regarding cinema have made suggestions on how to become ‘greener’ and more sustainable. The aim? To reduce the industry’s overall negative environmental impact. The ‘SPA’ (Sustainable Production Alliance) is a combination of the worlds leading film, television and streaming companies, supporting the objective of advancing sustainable initiatives. The Green Production Guide, prepared by the ‘SPA’, is an online toolkit designed to reduce industry carbon footprints by evaluating ways in which productions can be more environmentally friendly and energy efficient. One thing the guide, and other sustainable missions analyse, is the switch to LED technology, as it converts a higher percentage of energy into light, producing less heat, and in return less carbon emissions.

StageCraft aligns itself with sustainable industry governance, as ‘The Volume’ uses LED’s for its video wall, using 70% less energy then incandescent lights, further cutting its carbon emissions. Not only that, but it can bring locations to the comfort of ‘The Volume’! The production avoids having to travel sets, props and crews to distant locations, lessening fuel and time waisted.

Marissa Gomes (ILM visual effects producer): “You can switch from the Iceland to the desert locations all within the same day of shooting”

Video created by StudioBinder on YouTube, 2023

This groundbreaking technology has forced productions into a more efficient workflow, that draws pre and post production into one space. With crews covering 30-50% more pages a day, not only is virtual production sustainable environmentally, but it also saves time and money.

The Star Wars franchise has been used to explore film and TV’s environmental impact, due to its high production value. With the research conducted by ‘The EIF Project’, Star Wars, including ‘The Mandalorian’, continues to affiliate with improving sustainability goals.

StageCraft going global

Some other productions that have used StageCraft included ‘Thor: Love and Thunder’ (2022), ‘Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania’ (2023), and most recently ‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ (2024). Permanent volumes have been built in Los Angeles, London, and Sydney, whilst ILM have alluded to their ability to provide “pop up” sets, which allows multiple productions to reuse and access the video wall soundstage. Large productions can invest in StageCraft, which can eliminate other production elements that take up a lot of time and money, adding to the positive long-term efficiency, rather than having to create large sets from scratch and wasting materials.

The Future

Overall, the system looks more realistic then a green screen, and allows for quicker setups in a controlled environment. There is one drawback of this new technology, which is limited camera movement. This is for moving shots where someone could be running away for a long amount of time. But just as there were drawbacks of green screen, companies light ‘ILM’ continue to create and improve, whilst also having a sustainable practice in mind. The innovation initiated for “The Mandalorian” is beginning to revolutionise the film industry and push for standards towards sustainability.

Behind the Screen: What happened to the TV workforce and those wanting to enter the industry during lockdown? 1925845

Photo by GR Stocks on Unsplash

March 2020. The month and year of the first lockdown in the United Kingdom as a result of the covid-19 worldwide pandemic. Studying at Cardiff University at the time, this meant that I had to return home. Of course, this was the right thing to do. But while packing up my university bedroom, I couldn’t help but think about the work experience opportunities that a creative city like Cardiff had to offer.

Behind the camera

Indeed, we have seen the knock-on effect that the pandemic has had to those working in the television sector. Due to the close nature of a TV set, during the first lockdown, filming across the country was shut down. Unable to work from home, it has been estimated that 12,800 people working in Film, TV and Radio have lost their jobs since the beginning of the pandemic. In particular, this was, and still is, an extremely difficult time for freelancers who make up over a third of the main television broadcasters workforce.

Photo on-set by Jacob Capener on Unsplash
Photo of home laptop by Nubelson Fernandes on Unsplash

But with many of us confined to our homes, people started to turn to the screen and enhanced upon the power of social media to help support those working in TV. One example of this included a series of Doctor Who lockdown watchalongs, hosted by Emily Cook, which raised money for The Film and TV Covid-19 Emergency Relief Fund. This organisation provides grants for freelancers facing financial difficulties as a result of the pandemic and this event created a community of like-minded individuals in a time where people needed to feel connected the most.

Interview with Hollie-Jo Allan – Film and TV Hair and Make-up artist

In line with this, I decided to speak with Film and TV Hair and Make-up artist, Hollie-Jo Allan, about her experiences of being a freelancer during the pandemic. Her work includes War of the Worlds (Disney), The Crown (Netflix) The Nevers (HBO) and Wonka (Warner Bros.) – a highly anticipated feature film starring Timothee Chalamet and Olivia Colman.

Image by: Hollie-Jo Allan Instagram
Permission given by owner of the account

”Once productions started running again, we had to wear PPE, visors and sanitise our hands after every person [..] but I was very happy to return to work, although it was slightly difficult getting back into the long hours”

Hollie-Jo Allan – 2022

While Hollie-Jo explained that she could not work at all during lockdown, it did give her ”time to practice and learn new skills”. She went on to mention that ”through Instagram, a lot of hair and make-up designers were taking part in live videos to help other artists and explaining about how they achieved a lot of looks, or just a general chat for others in the industry”. Hollie-Jo expressed that this kept her motivated to continue developing her craft.

Educational opportunities in TV during lockdown

However, another impact of covid-19 also occurred to those wanting to gain on-set work experience. Due to the social distancing measures, this meant that even when productions could start filming again, most shadowing opportunities were placed on hold. So how did companies adapt to providing educational opportunities in the television sector during lockdown?

”My role is to ensure the next generation of TV and Film crew are coming into the industry”

Rhys Bebb – 2022

Screen Alliance Wales (SAW) is a not-for profit organisation who helps train and promote new talent within Wales. I spoke to Rhys Bebb, who is the Welsh Film and TV educational manager at SAW, about how they responded to the constraints of covid-19. In the interview, he explained how ”first and foremost, we adapted by delivering workshops virtually to students […] adapting resources to be accessed online and delivered by educators and learners”. This included a series of ‘jobs in TV’ sessions, including roles in the AD department and I myself participated in many of these since they were a great way to engage with new content.

Video: Screen Alliance Wales Showreel 2021 via YouTube

The role of user creativity

Individuals also turned to the screen for user-led content creation. For example, The National Film and Television school made a series of 60 second moving-image challenges, where individuals were encouraged to use household items to create their own short movies. The aim was to keep people motivated during lockdown and develop their own cinematic skills. The films can be found under the #NFTS60secchallenge on Twitter.

Here, digital platforms like YouTube became useful tools for tutorials on how to maximise the affordances of using a smartphone, including on how to calculate the lenses and various stabilisation methods. Ultimately, the role of digital technology in providing inspiration for individuals to both learn and create, would become fundamental during the lockdowns of 2020.

Video: Ultimate Beginner’s Guide to Smartphone Filmmaking via YouTube

The future of TV

The barrier to entry into the television sector has progressively changed. Indeed, Hesmondhalgh’s cultural industries theory once suggested that traditionally, companies would only employ those who possessed the appropriate specialised skills to maximise profit. However, with organisations such as SAW offering more paid training for those with no experience or qualifications, this has disrupted the traditional trajectory.

Moreover, something that has been highlighted over the last two years is the need to share these skills to maintain the TV workforce. Specifically, digital distribution has changed the way we learn and this has been significant in how the television industry brings in new talent (largely being pushed by the response of covid-19). Overall, to some extent, this has lowered the barriers to entry by bringing in new opportunities and improved accessibility.

Ultimately, I believe that these will benefit productions hugely in the future, since if there is more diversity within the workforce, then this will hopefully bring greater diversity in front of the screen too.

[All media and images have been used under ‘fair usage’ for educational purposes]

[All quotes by Hollie-Jo Allan and Rhys Bebb have been extracted from my personal interview with them]