“Ladies and gentlemen, please take your seats, the performance is about to start” A familiar announcement most of us will know. But during the Pandemic, theatres were forced to close, and all productions halted. A great financial loss for the arts sectors globally, however, once the restrictions were lifted and normality returned, people were desperate to get back to enjoying the theatre once more.
Over the years I have been to numerous theatre plays, concerts and shows of all genres, and in December, myself and my partner took his eight year old son to the Sherman Theatre to watch an adaptation of J.M. Barrie’s beloved Peter Pan. It was billed as a ‘New version by Catherine Dyson’ and was noted as being, ‘This fresh new take on a much-loved classic’ about growing up and ‘How we can all embrace living life in our own way’.
However, we were not expecting it to stray so far from home. In keeping with modern nuances, it explored the challenges of gender amongst some of the characters and other more adult themed conversations surrounding, death, loss, separation, and divorce. The play was aged 7+ but I did not expect to see a version of Wendy acting out giving birth, and the numerous talks of their parents separating was too much for the eight-year-old with us, who was still recovering from his own parents’ divorce. However, the highlight for the children was definitely the flying scenes which was provided by The No Fit State Circus.
Traditional or Woke?
We live in an era of inclusivity and diversity, when we take children to see old time classic stories on stage, I wonder if moving too far away from home will put the public off and deter them from spending their money at the box office. As the Daily Mail (2022) reported.
‘Is the west end going broke because it’s all gone woke?’ (2022)
With empty seats in many theatres and productions closing early because of poor tickets sales, one wonders if it is because people are not allowed to enjoy an evening out without having gender equality and LGBTQ issues thrust upon them.
‘When Andrew Lloyd Webber announces that his new Cinderella will be closing early on June 12, you know things are serious’. ‘Re-imagined Star Wars, Disney Stories and Marvel characters producing flop after flop’. (2022)
The phrase ‘Go woke or Go broke’ has long been paraded about and with productions trying increasingly to stay relevant and diverse, have theatre goers had enough of having these themes rammed down their throats when all they want is a night out and to be emersed in a make-believe world that is free from preaching to the masses? I am all for inclusivity when it comes to performers coming from a diverse background. For example, The chicken shed Theatre Tust have been in production for fifty years and produce outstanding shows, alongside workshops for children of all ages and disabilities. But children do not want to be reminded of their troubled homelife or emotional struggles. The theatre is meant to be a place of imagination, fantasy, magic and wonder and a place where they can escape the harshness of the real world for a few hours.
In this version of Peter Pan, running themes draw on ‘being yourself’, or be ‘who you want to be’ and dress how you want. In keeping with this theme, a creative approach is taken towards re-inventing the stories characters who have historically been portrayed by more traditional norms. Here we see characters acted by opposite sex’s, drawing on modern nuances of gender and identity. Such takes on traditional roles, have already been challenged within pantomimes, seeing the dames played by men and the prince’s valet by a girl, as stated in ‘The story behind the great British pantomime’ (2021)
Changing times or hard financial times?
We all love a trip to the theatre, but I worry that if production companies insist on re writing these traditional children’s classics to fit in with modern day trends and ideology, then they may struggle to climb back up from the financial losses encountered during Covid-19 especially the smaller community theatres and projects that already struggle to get adequate funding. This would be a great shame to our creative industries and potentially dissuade future generations from exploring a career in a vibrant and diverse sector. However, I do accept that we are moving towards a more creative and expressive era, where boundaries can be challenged.
I strongly believe that with many of these norms creeping their way into everyday life, they need to be adequately reflected within the creative industries, that we rely upon to reflect the real world. We need to be mindful of children’s innocence and the complex and often testing subject issues such as divorce and gender-transitioning. Using classical stories to convey many of the nuances around these issues can be dangerous if they only result in trivialising them.
All images and media used in this article are for fair usage for educational purposes only.